2007-01-23; 16:47:03 EST
Member Since
2002-09-17
Posts: 4946
Wisconsin man still alive after fall from 17th floor The Associated Press MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — A physicist calculated that a Wisconsin man was traveling about 69 mph when he hit a roof overhang after falling through a 17th-floor window in a downtown hotel. He remained in critical condition Tuesday, three days after the fall. Joshua Hanson, 29, a bar owner from Blair, Wis., was in town for a dart tournament. Police said he went out drinking Friday night in St. Paul, then returned to the hotel about 1:30 a.m. Saturday. When he got off the elevator on the 17th floor, he ran down a hallway and fell into a large window. The glass gave way and Hanson fell out and down about 160 feet onto an asphalt-covered overhang 160 feet below. “At this point, we’re regarding it as an accident,” said Lt. Amelia Huffman, a Minneapolis police spokeswoman. “We haven’t received any information that would indicate it was anything other than the result of tomfoolery and a little too much to drink.” Danny Austad, Hanson’s roommate back in Blair, said the prognosis was good and that he might be out of the Hennepin County Medical Center next week. “He had surgery on his leg. They put a metal rod in his leg. But basically, that’s it,” Austad said. “It doesn’t look like other major injuries. He got lucky. No back, no spinal, no head injuries.” A big reason for Hanson’s survival was probably that he hit a roof overhang, which collapsed a bit, rather than asphalt, said Jim Kakalios, a professor in the School of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Minnesota. He estimated that if Hanson fell about 160 feet — a hotel manager’s estimate — he was going about 69 miles when he hit and apparently broke through part of the overhang. Kakalios said the awning functioned like an automobile’s airbag, slowing the deceleration time which is vital because it’s not the long fall that kills, it’s the sudden stop at the end. “Even a small change in deceleration, if it goes from 1 millisecond to 3 milliseconds, it’s a factor of three. It’s the difference between a lethal force and a force that just knocks you unconscious,” he said. “The awning acted as a de facto airbag. Even a slight change in the increase in time can make a big difference.” It might have also helped that Hanson was drunk. In 1963, Richard G. Snyder wrote one of the major studies on long falls. In the paper, “Human Survivability of Extreme Impacts in Free-Fall,” Snyder noted that falling victims who were intoxicated had a “disproportionate survival rate” in such falls. He suggested that intoxicated people may be more relaxed when they fall, and perhaps that made the muscles more tolerant of impact forces. He made the same observation about suicidal paranoid schizophrenics. He qualified both observations by saying the matter needed more studySee the original archive post