The Rhodes 22 Discussion Group R22 Discussion Group

The Rhodes 22 Discussion Group


< prior

Back to Month

Go to Thread

Member Picture

Mark Whipple



hatch on foredeck

2019-12-05; 13:55:56 EST

Member Since

2019-10-09

Posts: 120

I've completely renovated a 28' Person Triton and done substantial work on
numerous other boats. I think in most cases it's true that it's cheaper to
buy someone else's renovations than to do them yourself, even if you don't
consider the value of your time. The same is usually true of a house: if
you redo your kitchen, it will probably increase the value of your house by
not as much as you spent on your kitchen. An individual boat owner usually
doesn't do renovations to make a profit, you do them because they provide
some sort of value to you. Hey, if you look at it from a strictly economic
perspective, owning a boat is never going to provide a monetary return on
your investment.

General Boats is in a very different position than an individual boat
owner. GB has much more experience and some economies of scale, so it make
more sense for Stan to renovate boats for resale. It would not surprise me
if the profit margins were modest in any case. GB creates their own market
for their unique product whereas an individual boat owner is just one of
many selling a used boat. Many folks would rather have a business that will
stand behind their product than a random individual.

All boats need work. My dentist recently bought a new 42' sailboat and had
a long list of items that need fixing. The calculation for me comes down to
this: am I willing to do the work that the boat needs to bring it up to the
condition you feel it should be in? When I asked myself this question
regarding my 30' Nimble yawl, the answer was "no" so I put her up for sale
and bought an R22 that I was willing to maintain. That calculation is
different for everyone.

Mark Whipple
Boston, MA

2000 R22
1986 Nimble 30 yawl (for sale)
1987 Hutchins Compac 16

See the original archive post
×

Message to Webmaster:

To use your email application to send a messsage to the webmaster rather than this form, .



×

Post to the Rhodes 22 Email List:



×

Sending Post:

Your post is being sent... waiting