< prior
Back to Month
Go to Thread
2020-04-25; 08:12:07 EDT
Member Since
2020-03-29
Posts: 139
I help set moorings for a small club and the float to anchor chain will fail if not inspected, there is often a swivel link near the middle that will go first. Sent from my iPhoneSee the original archive post
> On Apr 24, 2020, at 11:47 AM, Hank <hnw555 at gmail.com> wrote: > > ?You also need to ensure that the chain between the float and the anchor is > inspected. I used to have an Islander 36 and kept it on a mooring at the > Naval Academy. I got a call one day that my boat was missing. It turned > out that the chain had broken near the anchor and the marina had not > inspected it sufficiently. Fortunately, the weather was pretty calm and it > had gently floated across the river and had very little damage. The marina > was able to go over and bring it back that same morning. > > Hank > >> On Fri, Apr 24, 2020 at 11:37 AM Graham Stewart <gstewart8 at cogeco.ca> wrote: >> >> It is fascinating to me how what seemed like a simple question of whether >> to >> use the bow eye or the bow cleat has become so technical - and interesting. >> What an amazing list this is. >> >> Roger makes a distinction between tying up to a mooring or an anchor that I >> think is very important. In my earlier post I thought we were talking about >> moorings only but clearly that assumption was unwarranted. >> >> I think I should explain more carefully the risk of using chain with a >> mooring. Most moorings use chain between the float and the weight. That >> greatly increases the holding power and minimizes the scope that is >> required. However, the connection between the float and the boat - whether >> to the bow eye or cleat - should be nylon line. The case I mentioned where >> a >> neighbor had his boat break free and washed ashore occurred because he >> connected his mooring chain directly to his bow eye. With little to absorb >> the shock the chain snapped within a few hours of rough weather. >> >> Graham Stewart >> Agile 1976 Rhodes 22 >> Kingston Ontario >> >> >> >> >> -----Original Message----- >> From: Rhodes22-list [mailto:rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org] On Behalf >> Of >> ROGER PIHLAJA >> Sent: Friday, April 24, 2020 9:29 AM >> To: The Rhodes 22 Email List >> Subject: [Rhodes22-list] Swinging at anchor? >> >> Hi All, >> >> By the time I put up the pop top + enclosure and the cockpit boom room >> enclosure, S/V Dynamic Equilibrium has so much windage aft of the center of >> buoyancy; that, the bow always points strongly into the wind, like a big >> weather vane. This weather vane tendency is so strong it overwhelms any >> effect that the off center pull from using the bow chock/bow cleat vs. the >> bow eye might cause. Yes, in theory, the off center pull does generate a >> torque that might cause the boat to sail around its anchor. But, the >> weather vane effect from the excess windage aft completely dominates the >> boat's response to a wind shift. >> >> We don't have tidal current shifts here on the great lakes and rivers >> always >> tend to flow in the same direction. I'd be interested in hearing from >> ocean >> sailing Rhodies regarding whether anchoring from the bow eye vs. bow >> chock/bow cleat makes any difference in the way the boat lies to a current >> vs. the way it lies to the wind. My expectation is that there is very >> little difference; but, I'd like to hear from people that have actual >> experience. >> >> Regarding the question about using the bow eye vs. the bow chock/bow cleat >> when tied up to a mooring - Commercial moorings usually have a huge >> mushroom >> anchor or engine block buried in the mud and all chain rode up to the >> mooring ball. This setup has little, if any, shock absorbing properties. >> But, isn't the pennant from the mooring ball up to the boat usually nylon? >> Isn't that where the shock absorbing is supposed to occur? If so, you >> definitely wouldn't want to use chain here. Given the huge size of the >> mooring anchor and all steel chain rode, I don't think it makes much >> difference whether you use the bow eye or the bow chock/bow cleat when >> tying >> up to a mooring. That huge, deeply set, mooring anchor is not going to >> move >> no matter how much or how little scope you let out. >> >> Roger Pihlaja >> S/V Dynamic Equilibrium >> >> Sent from Mail<https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=550986> for Windows >> 10 >> >> From: Peter Nyberg<mailto:peter at sunnybeeches.com> >> Sent: Thursday, April 23, 2020 9:40 PM >> To: The Rhodes 22 Email List<mailto:rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org> >> Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Bow Eye vs. Bow Cleat? >> >> I am in total agreement with Roger on the benefits of anchoring from the >> bow >> eye rather than the bow cleat. >> >> My approach to doing so is a little different. I have 10' of 3/8" line >> with >> a thimble in one end permanently attached to the bow eye with a shackle. I >> refer to this line as my 'painter'. When I'm not anchored, the painter is >> looped over and tied off to the pulpit. After I've anchored, I attach the >> painter to the rode, and let out more scope so that the painter takes the >> load. >> >> In addition to effectively increasing your scope, this approach eliminates >> any chafing that might occur where the rode comes over the toe-rail. >> >> I originally tried this approach because someone way back in the archives >> suggested that it would reduce the tendency of R22 to swing on its anchor. >> Unfortunately I did not find this to be true to any significant extent. >> >> Peter Nyberg >> Coventry, CT >> s/v Silverheels (1988/2016) >> >> >>> On Apr 23, 2020, at 5:51 PM, ROGER PIHLAJA <roger_pihlaja at msn.com> >> wrote: >>> >>> Hi All, >>> >>> There is a real advantage to rigging the anchor line thru the bow eye vs. >> directly to the bow cleat. The choice of the bow eye vs. the bow cleat has >> a significant effect on the anchor scope. This is because the bow eye is >> ~1.5 ft closer to the water vs the bow cleat. For example, suppose we are >> anchoring in 7 feet of water. The bow eye is ~2 feet above the water and >> the bow cleat is ~3.5 feet above the water. Suppose we let out 65 feet of >> anchor rode. The scope using the bow eye is 65 / (7 + 2) = 7.2 The scope >> using the bow cleat is 65 / (7 + 3.5) = 6.2 A scope of 7.2 is sufficient >> for decent overnight holding with a minimum 65 foot radius swing circle. A >> scope of 6.2 is marginal for an overnight night stay. Sometimes, there >> isn't sufficient swing room to let out more anchor rode, say if you are the >> last boat to drop the hook in a crowded anchorage. In addition, it's >> considered bad anchoring etiquette to use up all the swing room in an >> anchorage even if you are the first one there. >>> >>> Fortunately, you don't have to tie off to the bow eye in order to get the >> scope advantage of using it. Simply run the anchor rode thru the bow eye >> first, then up to the bow cleat, and cleat it off. This will give you all >> the scope advantage of using the bow eye and all the ease of tying off to >> the bow cleat. When departing, reach down and hook the anchor rode with a >> boat hook below the bow eye. Pull the anchor rode on board, hang on to it, >> and then uncleat the rode from the bow cleat. Easy peasy and no stress on >> the knees! >>> >>> I always use the bow eye in the manner described above. There is just no >> reason not to, the extra safety margin on scope helps me sleep better, and >> I >> don't annoy my fellow boaters. >>> >>> Roger Pihlaja >>> S/V Dynamic Equilibrium >>> >> >> >>
To use your email application to send a messsage to the webmaster rather than this form, .
Your post is being sent... 