< prior
Back to Month
Go to Thread
2020-05-11; 10:14:37 EDT
Member Since
2004-10-28
Posts: 1565
I thought Stan has always said that the Rhodes 22 is not designed to rest on the keel. That's what I remember him telling me, at least.See the original archive post
On Mon, May 11, 2020 at 10:06 AM ROGER PIHLAJA <roger_pihlaja at msn.com> wrote: > No, as I stated earlier, I have a Lil Dude tandem axle boat trailer. But, > the physics of supporting, launching, and retrieving the boat don’t change > with the trailer manufacturer. The keel is much better to support most of > the weight of the boat vs. the bunks. > > Roger Pihlaja > S/V Dynamic Equilibrium > > Sent from Mail<https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=550986> for > Windows 10 > > From: Lowe, Rob<mailto:rlowe at vt.edu> > Sent: Monday, May 11, 2020 10:01 AM > To: The Rhodes 22 Email List<mailto:rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org> > Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Launch... and the story of an epic failure > > Roger, > Do you have the Triad trailer? It doesn't appear so. I'm not sure my > current Triad trailer has any rollers. How about other Triad owners? - rob > > ________________________________ > From: Rhodes22-list <rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org> on behalf of > ROGER PIHLAJA <roger_pihlaja at msn.com> > Sent: Monday, May 11, 2020 9:46 AM > To: The Rhodes 22 Email List <rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org> > Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Launch... and the story of an epic failure > > Alexis, > > What part of your bunks/support structure failed? Did the metal bunk > support poke right thru a rotten wooden bunk? Or, did the metal bunk > support structure fail somehow and leave a jagged shard to poke a hole thru > your hull? Anyway, your bunks and supports are all the same age. So, it’s > probably cheap insurance to go thru the whole system. > > On a related note, are your bunks properly adjusted to uniformly cradle > your hull? If the bunks were configured to place too much weight on one > bunk support; then, the failure mechanism would change from old age/wood > rot/metal fatigue/rust to an overload scenario. On my Lil Dude boat > trailer, most of the weight of the boat sits on a couple of HD rollers that > support the keel. These keel rollers are bolted directly to the trailer. > The bunks on my trailer function more like “outriggers” to keep the boat > from tipping over in a heavy crosswind or on a curve in the road. They are > not heavily loaded. Does your trailer have keel rollers? Are the keel > rollers properly adjusted to take most of the boat’s weight? If not, then > the bunks are being overloaded and this might have something to do with the > failure. If your trailer does not have keel rollers; then, you might > consider implementing them. Properly adjusted keel rollers will > dramatically reduce the load on your bunks, load the boat from the keel vs. > the hull when it’s on the trailer, and should make launch/retrieval much > easier. The attached photo shows the bunks & keel rollers on S/V Dynamic > Equilibrium’s trailer. The photo also shows what properly adjusted bunks > look like. For retrieval, I usually submerge the trailer until only ~6-12” > of the front of the bunks are exposed above the water. For launching, I > try to back the trailer in about the same amount. But, if I can get the > bunks submerged to about the 2nd bunk support from the stern, I can usually > push the boat off the trailer because most of the weight is on the keel > rollers, not the bunks. > > Roger Pihlaja > S/V Dynamic Equilibrium > > [cid:image003.jpg at 01D62778.F9E74390] > > Sent from Mail<https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=550986> for > Windows 10 > > From: Alexis Seigneurin<mailto:alexis.seigneurin at gmail.com> > Sent: Sunday, May 10, 2020 8:31 PM > To: The Rhodes 22 Email List<mailto:rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org> > Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Launch... and the story of an epic failure > > Roger, > > You’re right, I am very lucky the transom didn’t hit the ground! > > I cannot tell for sure that the hull had been punctured during the first > launch, but that is a possibility. That would explain why the boat was > stuck at that time, for sure. > > Regarding your question about the condition of the rest of the bunks, I > would say the wood was looking like it would soon need to be replaced, but > nothing alarming. I am going to replace all the bunks now, and also update > the brake line as well as the electrical wires. > > Yes, quite a few lessons learned, and quite a lot of work ahead of me! > > Alexis > > > ________________________________ > From: Rhodes22-list <rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org> on behalf of > Roger Pihlaja Home <roger_pihlaja at msn.com> > Sent: Sunday, May 10, 2020 12:38:34 PM > To: The Rhodes 22 Email List <rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org> > Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Launch... and the story of an epic failure > > Alexis, > > So, your hypothesis re the reason the boat was “stuck” on the first try > was the trailer bunk support had already punctured the hull and was > preventing it from sliding on the bunks? If so; then, this is also > probably what prevented the boat from sliding off the back of the trailer > when the trailer squatted down when you first tried to deploy the tongue > extension. If this had happened, the transom would have smacked the launch > ramp hard with all the rudder, outboard, motor mount, and hull damage that > implies! Thank your lucky stars. It sounds like you got away cheap with > just a small puncture thru the hull. Oh well, it sounds like multiple > lessons were learned that day. > > What’s the condition of the rest of your trailer’s bunk supports? > > Roger Pihlaja > S/V Dynamic Equilibrium > > Sent from my iPad > > > On May 9, 2020, at 10:34 PM, Alexis Seigneurin < > alexis.seigneurin at gmail.com> wrote: > > > > Hi there, > > > > If you remember my previous email, I was looking at doing something to > the brake line of my trailer so as to be able to extend the tongue. Since I > couldn’t find a trailer shop that wasn’t backed up, I decided to head to > the boat ramp - in Yorktown, VA - open the brake line, cap it, and get it > fixed up after the launch. > > > > So today, I went to the ramp. This is very nice ramp, and my father in > law and I thought that, maybe, we could manage to launch the boat without > extending the trailer’s tongue, and also without breaking open the brake > line. We gave it a try: the boat was almost afloat but would not come lose > off the trailer. Stuck on the bunks. I tried to give the boat a good push > but with no success. > > > > We decided to pull the boat back on the ground and extend the tongue. At > that point, the boat was not resting completely forward on the trailer, but > probably 2 feet back from the front. When we released the hitch, the > trailer swung back, resting on the trailer’s rear end. Ouch... > > > > We extended the tongue, hooked it back up to the car, and launched the > boat. My stress level was high, but the bilge was dry, so I was thinking > the boat had not any damage... I motored to the marina where I was going to > keep the boat, and I tied the boat to the dock. > > > > My father in law drove my car (and now empty trailer) to the marina, and > I realized one of the bunks was broken. The metal support was sticking out. > I started thinking the hull might be scratched, but not really more. > > > > Before leaving the boat at its new slip, I checked the bilge one more > time, only to find it full of water. No good. The decision to haul out came > immediately. I motored back to the ramp and we pulled the boat out, this > time pretty smoothly. > > > > Well, I now have a hole in the hull. And not a pretty one. The metal > piece punctured the hull (attaching a pic), so hauling out was the right > decision, or the boat would probably have sunk or suffered from bad water > damage. > > > > I left the boatyard, and I am hoping they can do a repair in the coming > weeks. I’m a bit scared of the cost. I am anticipating something around > $2000. What are you thoughts? > > > > In any case, this is totally my fault, and I learned things the hard > way. Hopefully this story will help other people avoid making the same > mistakes I made. > > > > Alexis > > > > [Image.jpeg] > > > > -------------- next part -------------- > > A non-text attachment was scrubbed... > > Name: Image.jpeg > > Type: image/jpeg > > Size: 1014868 bytes > > Desc: Image.jpeg > > URL: < > http://rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20200510/83fd62ef/attachment.jpeg > > > > -------------- next part -------------- > A non-text attachment was scrubbed... > Name: FE33BECB5C4A4E54945C7D4918421CA0.jpg > Type: image/jpeg > Size: 112640 bytes > Desc: FE33BECB5C4A4E54945C7D4918421CA0.jpg > URL: < > http://rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20200511/211f3ef7/attachment.jpg > > > >
To use your email application to send a messsage to the webmaster rather than this form, .
Your post is being sent... 