< prior
Back to Month
Go to Thread
2020-09-06; 16:16:11 EDT
Member Since
2008-12-25
Posts: 1035
Hi Stan, How much for a DIY upgrade kit, English version? Regards, Rick LangeSee the original archive post
On Sun, Sep 6, 2020 at 4:05 PM stan <stan at generalboats.com> wrote: > > > Boys and Girls, you are clogging up my inbox with this thread, to the > > point that you know I go out of my way not to do; step in. Of course > > Chis is correct: /"Are we reinventing the wheel, didn't Stan have a > > manual lift with a 6:1 pull? I seem to recall one at the boat show a > > while back and it lifted the motor pretty easily." / > We did. And of course Roger is correct. We used a direct in line > pulling design with most all the energy going to moving the motor > upward. Even folk conceived in the roaring twenties could raise and > gently lower that contaminating part of their boat. Actually with 6 > sheaves I think it was set up as a 7:1 ratio. Those smirking a GB > design, redesigned by some previous owner, are being innocently > disingenuous. > > Consider the chair. All 4 of its legs must work as designed or it > becomes a rocking chair. Not so with a 3 legged stool. A stretch of an > analogy but it points to the fact that any fault you are now > encountering is not the result of a 3 X 2 wheel pulley system that > worked heretofore, but is the fault of somehow new increased friction > being introduced in the moving of the trolley. So let's count those > ways, bearing in mind that sometimes creative prior owners improve on > our design - and sometimes, not being tuned into all the variables, they > do not: > > 1. The 2 aluminum channel tracks that the trolley rides in are distanced > so that there is almost zero side to side play of the trolley. If there > is noticeable trolley side to side play, /*or*/ the tracks are not > parallel, something or someone has altered the tracks from how they were > set when leaving the plant. More important: > > 2. The aluminum tracks must be in the same plane. To make this > possible on the curved transom of the boat, 2 long plastic parts are > individually shaped and vertically mounted on the transom for the > aluminum track channels to mount to so as to keep each track in the same > plane. (These 2 long plastic parts are mounted to the transom by machine > screws from inside the lazaret.) To the extent the aluminum tracks are > displaced from being in the same plane, friction increases the force > needed to raise the motor. What could displace the tracks from being in > the same plane? Other owners "repairs". (I see in this thread where an > owner replaced one of the two aluminum tracks with a home made plastic > design, perhaps not tuned into the same plane need. It did look like > they were so far apart the trolley could be removed simply by moving it > far enough to one side so the other side would lift out of its track. We > do read some reporting of strange noises and machine screw heads pulling > through transoms. Hulls built by others were thin and reinforced with > wood strips in the lazaret at the motor lift section of the transom. A > transom that could flex even slightly will take trolley tracks out of > the same plane and increase friction that has to be overcome. On older > recycled boats this gets caught and corrected, while it is probably > missed on privately bought boats. Hulls built in Edenton are coreless > and of solid glass so thick, transoms carry motor lift, rudder loads and > boarding ladder, all with no back up support. There is no flexing, even > when pulled from the mold. > > 3. Trolley sliders. If you have one continuous long slider on each > side of the trolley, it is not a factory installation and is a source of > considerable friction in non parallel and/or not in the same plane > tracks. Manual lift trolleys had 4 small wheels or sliders, two per > side, mounted on pins or axles that allowed them to adjust their angles > continuously to accommodate small track variations. If sliders are > multi fastened to the trolley and thus are not accommodative, friction > will increase. When we went to trolleys that could work manually or > electrically, we went back to the 3 legged stool idea. There is only one > slider on each side of the trolley's upper end. This reduces friction. > There being no 4 sliders, the third leg of the trolley is a large wheel > centered at the bottom of the trolley, that simply rides on the surface > of the transom. This allows for the trolley to start automatically > tilting at the right moment to further raise the motor clear of the water. > > Two final comments. To answer Peter's good questioning of 'if the > manual version was so good why did we go to the electric version?' One, > for a commercial reason. To expand our market appeal beyond the Peter > principle level. */The ladies love it./* The other, personal. I got > old and lazy and giving one demonstration sail after another at the > Annapolis Sailboat show, where both sailing and motoring is required and > the cockpit is full, I became inspired. Then during the demo sail I > would ask one of the prospects to tell the motor to come out of the > water. When he or she did and nothing happened, I would say, "No, no. > That motor is from Japan. You have to speak to it in Japaneses". > Luckily, never having a guest who could, I would make some gibberish > noise, press the remote in my pocket, take my bows, and maybe a deposit. > > The other comment is that all of the above is academic since when and if > I ever get partnering, I have an idea that may make inboard, retractable > electric propulsion competitive with outboards of any kind, and be > standard with each Rhodes, making this entire thread of historical > interest. > > stan > > >
To use your email application to send a messsage to the webmaster rather than this form, .
Your post is being sent... 