The Rhodes 22 Discussion Group R22 Discussion Group

The Rhodes 22 Discussion Group


< prior

Back to Month

Go to Thread

Member Picture

ROGER PIHLAJA



Pop Top Connection

2020-09-10; 08:15:06 EDT

Member Since

2002-08-01

Posts: 1438

Graham,

Although, at first glance, the present pop top slider design may look sort of crude, it’s actually pretty elegant.  Remember, there are 2 pieces of tackle that have their lower anchor points on the pop top slider, the boom vang and the Cunningham.  The snap shackle for the Cunningham actually attaches to the eye strap and the snap shackle for the boom vang actually attaches to the ring.  This way, the force from the Cunningham, which is vertical directly up the mast, is kept as close as possible to the mast.  The force from the Cunningham on the two machine screws attaching the eye strap to the pop top slider is almost entirely shear, which is the most mechanically efficient way to load a threaded connection.  In addition, by attaching the Cunningham to the eye strap vs. the ring, the clam cleat on the block automatically faces aft, thus facilitating ease of use from the cockpit.  Similarly, attaching the snap shackle for the boom vang onto the ring vs. the eye strap, automatically positions the clam cleat downward and moves it aft slightly, both of which help prevent the two pieces of tackle from getting fouled up on each other and makes the boom vang easier to use from the cockpit.

If the ring were simply welded onto the pop top slider, I think it might interfere with the pop top raising and lowering process.  i.e.  When the pop top is raised, the 1st step is to raise the aft end of the pop top up on its support arms until the spring loaded detents lock into position.  In this position, the front corner of the pop top might interfere with a fixed welded ring on the pop top slider.  The present design, with its eye strap and ring, automatically folds down out of the way.  Even with the present pop top slider design, it’s not the eye strap and ring that’s in the way if you attempt to raise the pop top with the boom vang and Cunningham in place, it’s the two pieces of tackle and all the associated line.  Similarly, it’s not the eye strap and ring that tend to chip up the front corner of the pop top, it’s the lower blocks and snap shackles on the Cunningham and boom vang that do the damage when they start flopping around.  A welded fixed ring wouldn’t change that.

Finally, if the ring is welded onto the pop top slider; then, that will be a critical weld.  There will be a lot of force on it.  I hope you are, or have access to, a certified welder.

Even after all these years, it’s fun to critically exam Stan’s ideas and designs that were so multifunctional.  He was way ahead of us all in anticipating and solving problems.  My boat is in its 44th season and it’s been sailed hard.  The pop top slider hasn’t given a bit of trouble.

Roger Pihlaja
S/V Dynamic Equilibrium


Sent from Mail<https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=550986> for Windows 10

From: Graham Stewart<mailto:gstewart8 at cogeco.ca>
Sent: Wednesday, September 9, 2020 10:32 PM
To: 'The Rhodes 22 Email List'<mailto:rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org>
Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Pop Top Connection

Roger:
I am thinking that it might be worth getting the ring welded to the plate at about a 30 degree an angle rather than having it flop around in the strap eye. Do you see a reason why that might not work?

Graham Stewart
gstewart8 at cogeco.ca


See the original archive post
×

Message to Webmaster:

To use your email application to send a messsage to the webmaster rather than this form, .



×

Post to the Rhodes 22 Email List:



×

Sending Post:

Your post is being sent... waiting