The Rhodes 22 Discussion Group R22 Discussion Group

The Rhodes 22 Discussion Group


< prior

Back to Month

Go to Thread

Member Picture

ROGER PIHLAJA



How to improve Rhodes 22 upwind performance?

2022-03-20; 13:14:19 EDT

Member Since

2002-08-01

Posts: 1438

Hi Dennis,

When I first got S/V Dynamic Equilibrium, I did some experiments with my outboard motor, a stopwatch, and a measured mile on Sanford Lake where I live.  Specifically, I was trying to determine what the “best” fore/aft trim was.  I moved ballast around to cause the boat to be 10 degrees down by the bow, level on the waterline, and 10 degrees down by the stern.  I had a graduated cylinder rigged up to measure fuel consumption and an accurate digital tach so I could reproduce the same engine RPM’s.  I choose the engine RPM to yield ~5 MPH to simulate sailing fast, so the effects of hull form wave making would be in the same range as sailing.  I made repeated runs over the measured mile at slightly different engine RPM’s until I found the engine throttle setting that yielded 5 MPH (actually a time of 720 sec over the measured mile with a running start) at each fore/aft trim setting and then measured the fuel consumption.  I did the experiments on a calm day when there was no other boat traffic and my lake has no currents.  I was trying to separate out drag from all the other factors, measured in terms of small differences in fuel consumption.  What I found was; down by the bow fore/aft trim was slightly better than level on the waterline and both were better than down by the stern.

I think it’s a question of drag.  Think about the hull shape behind the shoal draft keel back to the transom.  You want this part of the hull to smoothly direct the flow coming off the keel back to merge with the surrounding water.  When the hull is down by the stern, it acts like a set of landing flaps on an airplane wing  - lots of drag.  The difference between 10 degrees down by the bow to 10 degrees down by the stern is about 3% more fuel consumption and, I presume, that much more drag.

However, there is a big caveat to this experiment.  In waves, the boat depends on having sufficient reserve floatation in the bow to be able to punch thru waves.  Without this reserve floatation, the bow may submarine and you are in danger of pitchpoling, definitely the start of a bad day on the water!  But, for racing, especially on smooth water, slightly bow down trim is faster.

Yes, I know I’m a nerd!  But, a guy should be able to play with his toys, right?

Roger Pihlaja
S/V Dynamic Equilibrium

Sent from Mail<https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=550986> for Windows

From: Dennis McNeely<mailto:mcneelyd at site-solutions.com>
Sent: Sunday, March 20, 2022 7:36 AM
To: 'The Rhodes 22 Email List'<mailto:rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org>
Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] How to improve Rhodes 22 upwind performance?

Greetings all -
One other thought... if you don't have enough weight forward, the bow of the boat can't provide enough lateral resistance to counter the force of the sails.
Put differently, if too much weight is aft, the wind will push the sail, mast, and boat forward - but it will also push it sideways. That lateral push is countered by your rudder and centerboard, but it's also countered by the submerged bow of the boat. If the bow is too far out of the water or the stern is submerged too much, trying to balance your rig is a non-starter.
Stated differently, if the stern is weighted down and the bow is riding high, you'll be continually pushed off the wind, because you won't be able to get the center of effort (the place where the force of the wind pushes your boat) over the center of resistance (the spot on the keel where the water resists force from the wind).
The tighter you sail to the wind, the worse the effect will become. Having said all the above, I'm back to lurking :)
Dennis McNeely

See the original archive post
×

Message to Webmaster:

To use your email application to send a messsage to the webmaster rather than this form, .



×

Post to the Rhodes 22 Email List:



×

Sending Post:

Your post is being sent... waiting