The Rhodes 22 Discussion Group R22 Discussion Group

The Rhodes 22 Discussion Group


< prior

Back to Month

Go to Thread

Member Picture

ROGER PIHLAJA



How to improve Rhodes 22 upwind performance?

2022-03-23; 08:54:46 EDT

Member Since

2002-08-01

Posts: 1438

Mike,

We could have endless discussions about the optimum genoa size on the Rhodes 22.   With a roller furling headsail, there have to be many compromises in the materials and the design.  Especially the 175% genoa has to be light enough to inflate in light air, but strong enough to withstand heavy air without damage.  Achieving proper sail shape across such a wide wind speed range is also an issue.  The full draft shape desired for light air is all wrong for heavy air.  I’ll tell you what I did.

First of all, I upgraded the roller furler to a Harken Unit 0.  This system makes extensive use of Torlon ™ ball, roller, and needle bearings throughout to minimize friction.  My 25+ year old unit still spins as easily as a bicycle rim!  The Harken unit uses a streamlined luff foil with dual grooves in case you want to hoist 2 headsails.  There are independent upper and lower swivels to take advantage of the superior sail shaping technology available with foam luff pads on the genoa.

Then, I needed a sail to go with the Harken roller furler.  After a lot of research and discussions with sailmakers, I decided to go with JSI in St. Petersburg, FL.  They built me a 150% genoa with bi-radial construction made with  Bainbridge Cruise-Lam ™ sailcloth, stitched together with Kevlar thread.  Cruise-Lam ™ sailcloth is a 5 layer composite with an inner Mylar core, a Kevlar scrim on each side of the core (think coarse mesh), and Dacron outer skins for abrasion and UV resistance.  The composite sailcloth is both light enough to inflate in light air and strong enough to maintain sail shape in heavy air.  Then, to maintain proper sail shape as the sail is furled, there Is a foam luff pad.  The foam luff pad works with the independent upper and lower swivels on the roller furler to quickly take up the extra sailcloth as the sail is furled.   Starting with a full draft light air sail shape, the more the sail is furled, the flatter the sail shape becomes.  I didn’t have them install a “UV stripe” made of Sunbrella ™ acrylic fabric on the foot and the leech because the sailmaker advised; that, it would make the sail too stiff and heavy to inflate in light air.  Instead, I use my spinnaker halyard to hoist an ATN “Genoa Sleeve” over the furled up genoa.  The Genoa Sleeve is made of Sunbrella ™ and completely protects the genoa in the manner of a snap-on mainsail cover.  In fact, my mainsail cover and Genoa Sleeve are both from JSI, both in matching Pacific Blue Sunbrella™.

This sail has been a remarkable success.  I’ve never had to repair it and the sail shape looks as good today as when it was new.  Despite the high tech composite construction, there is no sign of fatigue or UV degradation even after all these years of use.  It was expensive; but, I’ve certainly gotten my years of use out of it.  Realistically, with the composite sailcloth, bi-radial construction, foam luff pad, and Harken roller furler; I can get good sail shape from 150% down to about 100%.  Furl it up any smaller than that and the rolled up luff is such a big “lump” on the leading edge of the sail; that, the air flow is disturbed all the way to the leech no matter how you trim it.  At that point, the furled up genoa is just some sail area you put up to balance the helm.  I should really buy a 100-110 % heavy air jib for conditions like that.

I have sailed on Rhodes 22’s with the 175% genoa.  The big genoa is a little harder to tack in light air.  But, you soon learn proper technique and get used to it.  For me, the tradeoff was giving up the relatively rare days when there was enough wind to sail at all, even with the 175% genoa vs. the more numerous days when you need to reef down to 100%.  Often, when you could fly the 175%, the wind is flucky, changing directions all around the compass, sometimes dying all together.  At best, sailing is not much fun under those conditions.  Whereas, the Rhodes 22 comes alive when the small craft warnings go up!  I tried to choose a genoa size that would work for  about 80% of the my sailing conditions.

I also have a fully battened, conventional mainsail and the old style, high aspect ratio hydrofoil, centerboard and rudder.  Up to about 20 knots wind speed, I can consistently achieve ~85 degree tacking angles.  That’s pretty good for a trailerable cruising sailboat.  Above about 20 knots, my windward performance rapidly falls off.  Again, a smaller headsail would probably help.

Anyway, that’s how I approached this issue.  I’ll be interested in hearing what you do.

Roger Pihlaja
S/V Dynamic Equilibrium


Sent from Mail<https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=550986> for Windows

From: Donald Simons via Rhodes22-list<mailto:rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org>
Sent: Tuesday, March 22, 2022 7:45 PM
To: The Rhodes 22 Email List<mailto:rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org>
Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] How to improve Rhodes 22 upwind performance?

Mike,
Our Rhodes came with a working jib as well as the 150 Genoa. I replaced our jib sheets and route the new ones outside the upper shrouds.  I then "re-purposed" the old ones and route them outside of the forward lower, and inside the rear lower.  I attached snap hooks to make switching the sheets easier, but they do occasionally hang up on the shrouds.
Don Simons,  Ithaca, NY
    On Tuesday, March 22, 2022, 12:38:01 PM EDT, <mm.bizlist1 at gmail.com> wrote:

 Roger,

Thanks again for taking the time to respond so thoughtfully.

1) My jib cars are all the way forward.  I agree that the jib tracks don't provide the proper range of positions with the 130% genoa.  In regards to optimum jib size for the Rhodes 22, I had posted that question to the forum before I bought my Rhodes, and there seemed to be some consensus that a 130 was the best compromise.  I would like to sail a boat with one of the larger sails, but I imagine they would be harder to tack in light air (typical of my area), although having more sail area would also be beneficial.  My genoa has telltales without windows, but in most cases you can easily see the leeward telltale through the sail.  Because of the limitations imposed by the jib tracks, I have limited control over the twist in the headsail.

If you had it to do over again, would you stay with the 150 genoa or go with a different size?

2) I hadn’t realized that there is a factory option for additional jib tracks.  I will check with Stan regarding those, but I suspect the installation process would be non-trivial.  Based on your comments, it also seems that they would only be useful when I partially furl the sail in heavier wind and wouldn't help give me better sheeting options with the full sail.

3) I am slightly familiar with barber haulers.  They are generally used off the wind to help hold the clew further outboard with less twist than would be possible with the inboard jib fairleads.  I have thought about how to install a barber hauler on my Rhodes but haven't attempted it.

4) My mainsail is definitely fully unfurled.  The outhaul allows me to pull it out within a couple of inches of the end of the boom.  I also have concerns about the position of the draft--it also seemed too far aft to me, but the Rhodes running rigging doesn't give one much control over that.  Has anyone ever tried using a Cunningham with the IMF sail?  Would that be potentially dangerous?

5) My main does have a leech line, which is fully eased.  The sailmaker speculated that a prior owner had tightened it too much for too long which may be why it is permanently cupped.  I'm beginning to see that a new main could be required to solve multiple issues.  By the way, I had tightened the outhaul because the wind gusts had picked up quite a bit--it started out much looser.  Your discussion about the "groove" is spot on.

6) Finally, have you or anyone else tried routing the jib sheets between the shrouds as I described?  For me it was a positive change, but it seems I have other issues that need to be addressed to improve my windward performance.

Thanks Roger!


Mike McKay
s/v Liber (2006/2018)
Allatoona Lake
Acworth, GA




Sheets.pdf
See the original archive post
×

Message to Webmaster:

To use your email application to send a messsage to the webmaster rather than this form, .



×

Post to the Rhodes 22 Email List:



×

Sending Post:

Your post is being sent... waiting