2014-10-31; 17:50:25 EDT
Member Since
2014-05-06
Posts: 3821
Hi Rummy: Interesting article: There are many ways to skin a cat and which way is best depends on the particular circumstances and inclinations of the individual doing the work. Here is a link to another article in Good Old Boat on the same topic: http://www.goodoldboat.com/reader_services/articles/delamination.php Everything I have read about epoxy tells me that epoxy by itself is too brittle. You can hit solid epoxy with a hammer and it will shatter. In boat construction it is the combination of the epoxy and wood that gives the strength and moisture resistance of the epoxy and the flexibility of the wood that you need. So while I am sure an area of solid epoxy works fine for small areas I would worry about pooling a large amount of epoxy as the deck core. Cost would also become a question for larger areas. The other problem for me is that by the time you have drilled dozens of holes and then ground down the surface, you might just as well have removed the skin in one piece, replaced the rotten core with wood and epoxy and then bonded the skin back on. That way you are not guessing where the rot is as you can actually see it. I should mention that in my case the deck had become soft over a large area but the skin was not deformed. So a fix for a small area would not be appropriate. In my case I had read a number of articles where I was told that one can identify where rot is by tapping with a tack hammer or wooden handle. Good luck with that! After seemingly hours of tapping I still had no clue so I started to remove the skin in chunks where I guessed there would be rot only to find that the wood was solid - just detached from the skin. The tapping could not distinguish between an air space and rot - at least not for a person with my level of experience. Drilling into the core is better but even that was not conclusive for me. That was one of the reasons that I went to the extreme of removing deck and completely removing the core. In doing so I discovered that the one area that actually had rot had sounded rock solid when I was tapping because it occurred around the air vent for the holding tank on the bow where the fibreglass is twice as thick as the rest of the deck. Personally, I would not trust tapping as a reliable indicator alone. Nor would I trust a moisture meter as that turned out, in the hands of a presumed "expert" to be dead wrong as well. I would want to get in there and see it firsthand. I really wanted to know that I had replaced ALL of the rot and I could not see how I could be confident of that without being able to see the core and what I was doing. From what I learned taking the deck off, and if I were to do it again under the same circumstances, I would cut around the entire foredeck and lift the whole skin off - hopefully in one piece. I would then replace any wood that was wet, inject epoxy into the plywood if drilling indicated air space between the layers of the plywood and then re-bond the skin to the core using epoxy mixed with high adhesive thickener. Then I could rest easy and save a considerable amount of work over what I ended up doing. I would hate to think that I went to a lot of work fixing one spot now knowing that there was another wet spot a few inches over that I missed completely. Hopefully these articles and discussion will at least give anyone who is considering major deck repair a number of alternative strategies that they can consider. GrahamSee the original archive post