2014-12-10; 07:26:47 EST
Member Since
2014-05-06
Posts: 3821
Graham, The newer boats all use a plastic rub rail. Aluminum was scrapped years ago. NP1 sticks to anything it comes in contact with. It is used in roofing because it seals during expansion and contraction events. It also has a 15 year direct exposure guarantee from the manufacturer. You are correct in that you don't want to apply more than you can install the pop rivets and tighten within an hour or so. It takes several days to fully cure, but becomes water tight after skinning over. It never fully "hardens". I did this procedure approximately fifteen years ago on Rumrunner and to this day it's still water tight. Rummy In a message dated 12/9/2014 11:00:25 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org writes: As expected, Rummy's instructions are spot on excellent. I might add a few additional bits that he does not mention and Rummy can correct me if I am wrong. On my boat (1976) not all of the rivets came all the way through to the aluminium rub rail. To remove all of the rivets I had to remove the aluminium rail and I was unable to do that without destroying it as any bends that you put into the rail cannot be straightened. So plan on replacing the rub rail with a new one. The sealant you decide to use might determine how much you should do at one time. I am not familiar with the sealant Rummy uses but as it is intended for roofs, I suspect it stays very soft. Perhaps Rummy will advise what happens to the sealant he uses as it cures. But if you use a sealant that hardens up when it cures such as any of the marine sealants you will want to close the gap with rivets or bolts before the sealant cures. If you seal all the way around the boat and then start adding the rivets the sealant will cure before you will be able to compress the join. You will no doubt find that everyone has strong and differing opinions about what sealant to use and in the end you will need to go with your best judgement. Obviously you want a top quality sealant that will last indefinitely. You will also probably want one that has excellent expansion capabilities. As the deck and hull expands and shrinks and also flexes, it is important that the sealant has the ability to tolerate that change. Even sealant that has excellent elasticity will not work if it is applied too thin. Boat windows made of Plexiglas and attached to the exterior without hardware use a combination of special thick double-sided tape and high flex sealant - usually Dow-Corning 795. The tape is extremely adhesive but also maintains about a 1/8" gap between the window and the cabin side that allows the sealant to be thick enough to work properly. The 795 sealant is extremely flexible but also extremely adhesive. The main issue in the case of the hull deck join, in my opinion, is not so much adhesion, as the rivets will hold the boat together, but rather to maintain a good permanent and flexible seal. You might consider using butyl for this (the form that comes in a tube) but because it would add nothing to the strength of the join I would double up on the rivets/bolts. One argument that might favour bolts over rivets is that you can tighten the bolts as needed while rivets apply maximum pressure. If you want to make sure that the sealant is not all squeezed out of the join, bolts would give you that degree of control. With butyl, that should be less of a concern. There is a lot (too much) of information on the net about the pros and cons of various sealants. I would be interested to know which sealant Stan would recommend. Widen the gap with wooden wedges/shims ahead of where you are injecting the sealant to ensure that the sealant is injected well into the gap. Put the shims in first as needed and then remove each as you reach that point with the sealant. That will allow you to get more sealant into the join and the removal of the shim will squeeze the sealant immediately while it is still uncured. Another thing I would worry about is removing all of the rivets at once. The hull is very thin and very flexible at the top and I would worry about the whole thing changing shape one all of the rivets and sealant has been removed. Assuming that the boat is on its trailer when you do the job and knowing that the trailer applies uneven pressure to the hull, I would not want to find that the boat hull and deck became misaligned. That might not happen but at the same time you can avoid the risk by doing sections of about 8' at a time. Remove the rivets in one section only after the previous section has been sealed and riveted/bolted. Alternatively, replace some of the rivets (say every 4') temporarily with bolts that can be easily removed as you work your way around the boat. I would definitely add more rivets or bolts to those presently on the boat especially around the fore deck. I think that the waves on the bow work the hull-deck join as the hull is very flexible in comparison to the rigid deck and that is where the sealant can/will break. Certainly on my boat it was only at the front section that I had trouble with leaks. Finally, if you use rivets, I would definitely use washers with them. Good luck GrahamSee the original archive post