2015-01-11; 11:03:58 EST
Member Since
2014-05-06
Posts: 3821
Hmmm. I guess the best I could suggest for an upper limit to shroud tension is 2100 pounds, the breaking strength of 1/8" 1 x 19 stainless steel cable. You could fire up a CAD program and doing a stress analysis of the replacement chain plate to verify it can take that load, but that seems a bit over the top. I guess I'd go back to the fact that the Rhodes' forestay is loaded more heavily than the lower shrouds, both at rest and dynamically. The pin for Magic Moments' forestay is 3/16", which will shear considerably sooner than the 1/4" pin used by the part you're considering at http://www.rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20150110/e0fd47a f/attachment.jpg. In addition, the new part appears to be a doubled piece of stainless, 0.1" thick - which is thicker than our more-heavily-loaded forestay tang. That leads me to believe the replacement part will take the load from the lower shroud to its mounting bolts without a problem. The new chain plate has 2 - 1/4" mounting holes, and a 1/4" coarse thread bolt has 1,750 pounds of tensile strength (if you believe charts on the Internet). So the bolts should be adequate to take the 2,100 pound load to the backing plate. Sooo... my vote is that the replacement part seems OK. The last consideration is the size of the backing plate and / or epoxy plug securing those bolts. To my thinking, this is the weak link in the chain, but I don't have anything to reference for a suggestion. Good luck with it. Dennis Magic Moments Getting my sailing fix from books till the water softensSee the original archive post