2015-03-26; 09:33:06 EDT
Member Since
2014-05-06
Posts: 3821
Alex: I doubt that you will get any detractors for the Rhodes 22 on this list. If there are detractors, they probably have gone elsewhere. As you said, every boat is a compromise and involves a choice of features and characteristics that only you can identify. I love the Rhodes because I want a boat the has comfortable accommodation both inside, in the cockpit and on deck without being one of those high freeboard floating bedrooms. I want a boat the sails comfortably and well but I don't have any inclination to race unless someone is coming up behind me in which case my wife says I turn into a frantic animal - but what does she know. If racing is your thing and matters more than accommodation and comfort some other boat might be your best choice but that said the Rhodes is not a cow either and for normal cruising I think most people would be quite happy with its performance. If, however, you want to use the boat as a small cruiser for trips lasting weekends or weeks at a time, I doubt that you will ever regret having the Rhodes. The swing keel/centreboard arrangement alone is wonderful. One advantage of the Rhodes is this list. There is a community of people out there who have run into every problem and fixed anything that can break. So you always have a great source of help for any sailing issue or problem you might face. You asked about longevity, and given that my boat is now about 35 years old perhaps I can give you some perspective on that. First, I should stress that newer boats are built much better than the older boats so they should run into fewer problems. That said, nothing lasts forever and in my case I have been actively and exhaustively rebuilding my boat for about 4 years now and still have two years to go. I am on lake Ontario so work is restricted to summertime. Some think that is crazy. No, EVERYONE thinks that is crazy. The loss of the use of the boat for so long, the expense involved and the time taken up cannot be justified for a boat that was worth a few thousand dollars when I began. That said I don't regret the decision because I have thoroughly enjoyed doing the work - except maybe scraping 35 years of antifouling off the bottom and buying a newer boat was not in the cards for me. This is my second boat restoration - the first took 10 years - so either that proves that rebuilding boats can be its own reward or I just can't learn from experience. I like the design of the Rhodes so much I just doubt that any other boat would satisfy me now. The point here is that while nothing lasts forever, there is also virtually nothing on the Rhodes that cannot be restored to new condition either. The only boat that I have seen the people on this list completely write off was one that had sat in a field for years while the deck core completely disintegrated. I did fairly extensive repair of the core on my deck but it was not beyond salvage. Certainly, however, If I were looking at used Rhodes 22, or any other boat, the first thing I would check out thoroughly would be the condition of the deck core. Newer Rhodes have closed cell foam core so deck problems should be much less of a problem if they ever occur. I am not sure when the switch from plywood to foam core occurred but I would definitely give considerable weight to the deck core material if considering a used boat. I have the standard mast without mainsail furling and from what I have seen in the threads on this list, I would be reluctant to spend the significant sum involved in getting this option. It seems to me to be more trouble than it is worth but on the other hand I have not had that gear to compare and I am pretty sure that having expressed my doubts, others will be prompted to express adamant disagreement. In general, if you want a beautifully designed, quality built, cruising small sailboat I can't imagine that the Rhodes 22 will ever disappoint. If you buy used make sure the boat is thoroughly and knowledgeably inspected or get a boat that has been rebuilt by Stan in which case it seems entirely unlikely that you will run into any serious problems. GrahamSee the original archive post