2015-03-26; 15:13:56 EDT
Member Since
2014-05-06
Posts: 3821
Alex, You sure know how to open up a can of worms. I'm sure you will get some of our sleepy owners awake with this thread. In short, not a slow boat, great for what you want it for. I own an 88 model that looks like new and sails beautifully. It is easy to trailer, take down and set up. It can be done by a single person. Rummy Lake Hartwell, SC In a message dated 3/26/2015 12:39:41 A.M. Eastern Daylight Time, rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org writes: Hello Rhodies. I’ve been lurking on this list for a couple weeks and cyber shopping for months. I get to meet Stan in June and finally see the Rhodes 22 I hope to fall in love despite her aged looks. I also wanted to query the fleet I’ve been sailing on a Buccaneer 18 for over 30 years. I started crewing on the same boat as a kid. The Bucc is a described in Sailor Anarchy as “a fast boat. Initially very tender, but firms up just before she capsizes” She lacks a self bailing cockpit. Mine is not set up for racing, I just play around. I’m looking for a couples cruiser I can dock at the local reservoir (southern Ohio) and sail more frequently than my dingy. I also hope to take her to Lake KY or the Great Lakes for a long weekend once or twice a year. I tend to keep equipment forever, and am looking for a quality boat that will still be serviceable in 20 plus years when I retire. Therefore I’m avoiding plywood decks and iron centerboards. I’d like a stable boat I can take my dad out on. He taught me to sail the Bucc when I was a kid, but is no longer agile. I wanted to give the group a chance to sell me on this boat My experience is almost entirely one design on inland waters where few other sailboats play. My Great Lakes experience is mostly paddling a canoe down the shore (bits of 4 lakes). I’m looking at a few other trailer sailors. Catalina 250 is reportedly very difficult to launch without a full team and plenty of time. It is more boat then I want. Hunter 23.5 Day sailor with accommodations suitable for a quickie after sunset, but not necessarily designed for a full weekend. The lack of a real head is a negative. I did like the 23.5 when I saw it in a boatyard. I haven’t seen a 240 yet. The 250 reportedly makes a lot of leeway. Not many of these heavy boats were made.. The 260 is too wide to legally trailer. Macgregor 26 S (not the motor cruiser) is analogous to a Chevy Impala. Fast but poor handling, they are inexpensive and plentiful. To misquote Dr. Who: ”It’s smaller on the inside”. Predictable necessary upgrades include a roller furler jib, new sails, an ida sailor rudder, reseal the fittings and upgrade the head door. I’d likely also end up rewiring it. I’ve rafted up with one. She kept up with my Buccaneer fairly well, being light and long. The styling is a product of the 80’s but so am I! Percision 23: I haven’t seen one. The reputation is unpredictable quality in a family cruiser. Not many built. Good performance, but no head. Rhodes 22. Appears to be an older Mercedes. I haven’t seen one yet. The reputation is well engineered but expensive. Refined handling, but a slow boat. Relatively good access to the foredeck may be vital in Lake Erie chop. Many parts custom to ‘Mercedes’ (GB) which is not a problem as long as Mercedes remains healthy. I will look at a recycled or recently recycled boat out of the corral. I doubt I will commission a new sloop. I’m not expecting an Ultimate 20, but hate to entirely sacrifice performance. The IMF seems very cool, at the cost of roach and battens. Does anybody know how it affects Portsmouth numbers, etc.?. Perhaps Stan can invent ‘in boom furling’. Every boat is a compromise. I appreciate any insight or thoughts from the Rhodes fleet. Alex Cole Urbana OhioSee the original archive post