< prior
Back to Month
Go to Thread
2015-06-05; 09:37:48 EDT
Member Since
2014-05-06
Posts: 3821
Graham: keep the pictures coming. I love your description of projects! Fair fiberglass, fair winds, and hopefully soon following seas! Bob (palatka)See the original archive post
> On Jun 4, 2015, at 10:44 PM, The Rhodes 22 Email List <rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org> wrote: > > Bob: > > I hope you are wrong too but my backup plan, should the tape not hold, is to > add screws right through the tape into the cabin side. In that case I am no > worse of having used the tape as it makes an excellent gasket that should > seal the screw hole and still has serious adhesive qualities while leaving a > space for the sealant. At least now I have a better idea than my first time > doing this about how to use the screws. I filled the space between the liner > and the cabin outer skin with epoxy coated plywood so I will have a very > solid core to screw into. I will drill the hole through the fibreglass and > acrylic larger than the screw shank to allow for expansion and let the > plywood hold the screw. But I am hoping that is not necessary. > > The join for the pieces that I stuck together with the tape in my highly > scientific experiments will not come apart without breaking the Lexan I was > using. The lifting force I applied to separate the pieces was far greater > than the force generated by the spring back of the bent panels and the curve > the join was subjected to was way beyond the curve that the acrylic will > have to take when applied to the boat. Of course I was not able to duplicate > the effects of sun and flex over the years. I have read everything I could > find on the tape so I feel encouraged by that but I won't know for certain > until I try. > > I was using lexan for my experiments as I had the scraps available but for > the new windows I am using acrylic (Plexiglas) which, according to the > supplier does not have the limitations that you mention in terms of an > outside and inside. I plan to cover the edges with the sealant anyway. > > Accurate placement of the window panels is still my biggest worry. > > Graham > > > -----Original Message----- > From: rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org > [mailto:rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org] On Behalf Of The Rhodes 22 Email > List > Sent: June-04-15 4:17 PM > To: The Rhodes 22 Email List > Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Window replacement update > > Graham: I too like your approach and applaud your meticulous efforts. If > we are placing bets i place mine that the double sided adhesive will fail > miserably. > I Hope i am wrong buddy! > > Bob (palatka) > >>> On Jun 3, 2015, at 4:42 PM, The Rhodes 22 Email List >> <rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org> wrote: >> >> Bob: >> >> Thanks for the suggestion. Last time I did this I used screws and >> would like to avoid using any hardware at all this time. The >> difference in expansion between the lexan and the fibreglass resulted >> in the lexan breaking around many of the screws - especially at the >> ends of the Lexan panel. The only way to use hardware is to enlarge >> the holes. Make sue the screws are dead centre, use screws with a >> washer of screws with a broad head and be very particular about how >> tight the screws are. They need to be tight enough to seal the joint, >> especially with neoprene gasket that must be compressed to seal, but >> loose enough to allow for expansion. No one can tell me how to >> determine what that torque should be. Screws look stronger but in practice > create as many problems as they solve. >> >> Many boats are manufactured today using the materials and process I >> intend to use and without the use of any hardware. So the method is >> not new and was certainly not invented by me. There is quite a bit on >> the internet about it and some of the info and videos for the tape by >> 3M are quite impressive. If the tape will hold glass panels in tall >> buildings around the world or steel panels on trailers I doubt that >> melting will be a problem. Besides, in Ontario we celebrate when the >> ice melts. The silicone is not used primarily as the adhesive, the >> tape does that, but it is used to seal the joint. It remains soft and > flexible whether hot or cold. >> >> The special problems associated with using this hardware-free method >> for attaching acrylic panels to the Rhodes are: >> 1) that the cabin sides on the Rhodes are curved - particularly >> lengthwise but also twist vertically. The spring-back of the panel >> wants to pull the joint apart so the adhesive qualities of the tape >> have to be sufficient to overcome this until the panel eventually sets in > the shape of the cabin. >> 2) the panels are large and that means greater expansion differences >> between the acrylic and the fibreglass - so the tape and sealant must >> be sufficiently flexible to allow for that movement and, >> 3) the size of the panel and shape of the cabin make placing the panel >> in the exactly correct position and with no opportunity to reposition >> it likely to be difficult. At this point I am pretty confident about >> the ability of the tape and sealant to handle the first two points but >> the third point is another matter and is the part I worry about most. But > who knows? >> >> If the panels pop off for any reason I will let everyone know what >> went wrong. >> >> >> >> Graham >> >> >> >> -----Original Message----- >> From: rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org >> [mailto:rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org] On Behalf Of The Rhodes 22 >> Email List >> Sent: June-03-15 1:48 PM >> To: The Rhodes 22 Email List >> Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Window replacement update >> >> Graham: i would consider a black neoprene gasket with small through >> bolts (or machine screws). I think it would look good and be less >> likely to leak or fall off. Down here in florida when adhesive gets >> hot it just melts and lets go. Just MHO. :-) Bob (palatka) >>>> On Jun 3, 2015, at 12:31 PM, The Rhodes 22 Email List >>> <rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org> wrote: >>> >>> Mary Lou: >>> >>> I will paint the inside of the acrylic panel everywhere except where >>> the openings will be. I intend to do this by removing the protective >>> paper everywhere except the port opening, then paint the panel and >>> finally remove the paper over the opening once the panel is installed. >>> In the picture I provided with the panels painted the paper covering >>> is still over the port area so it looks solid. You can't see the >>> paper covering in the picture. I could remove the paper before I >>> install the panel but it seems sensible to leave that area protected >>> from scratches and any sealant that might get smeared on it during >> installation. >>> >>> I have attached a picture showing the plywood template, for the >>> panel, the Formica template (white) for the opening and the two >>> acrylic panels with the protective paper still on and the opening areas > marked. >>> >>> The acrylic panel is deep tinted so perhaps nothing will show through >>> but the tinting is not opaque and I suspect that in sunlight the grey >>> tape and white cabin will show. I don't have a spare piece of the >>> tinted acrylic to test this as I had the dealer cut the original >>> panel for me using a plywood template that I provided. I should have >>> asked for some scrap piece. I did have some clear acrylic that I used >>> to test painting and the cutting and removal of the paper. I have >>> attached a picture of the clear acrylic, partially painted and with >>> the opening protective paper pealed back on both sides. That might >>> make >> what I am describing a litter easier to follow. >>> >>> I have attached a picture of the boat with the lexan windows that I >>> attached back in 1995. The picture was taken 20 years later when the >>> paint had pealed and you can see the cabin and peeling paint under >>> through the Lexan. Hence my obsession with using the right paint. >>> >>> For more about my paint selection I have attached a picture of panels >>> of Lexan coated with various paints along with observational comments. >>> I think it demonstrates fairly well why the barbeque paint seemed >>> superior for this task. >>> >>> I hope that helps. >>> >>> Graham >>> >>> >>> -----Original Message----- >>> From: rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org >>> [mailto:rhodes22-list-bounces at rhodes22.org] On Behalf Of The Rhodes >>> 22 Email List >>> Sent: June-02-15 11:51 AM >>> To: The Rhodes 22 Email List >>> Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Window replacement update >>> >>> Nice write up Graham but I must be missing a sentence or an email or >>> something. >>> >>> If you are going to have Lexan windows, why paint them? I read the >>> part about "to make sure that the grey tape and white sides of the >>> cabin did not show through" but if you are painting the whole window >>> why >> use Lexan at all? >>> Or can you still see out through the paint? do the windows let light in? >>> >>> I'm confused. >>> >>> Mary Lou >>> 1991 R22 Fretless >>> (recycled 1998) >>> still on the hard >>> but just about ready >>> to splash for the season >>> in Rock Hall, MD >>> >>> >>> >>> At 11:16 AM 6/2/2015, you wrote: >>>> For those who are interested in replacing cabin ports with acrylic >>>> panels, I thought I would bring you up to date on my highly >>>> scientific experiments using the method of attaching windows without >>>> using any hardware. >>>> >>>> My experiments were intended to demonstrate for me the strength of a >>>> joint using Dow Corning silicone # 795 and 3M brand tape VHB 4991 >>>> and the paint I intended to use to coat the inside of the acrylic panel. >>>> >>>> First, I joined some pieces of Lexan I had using the tape and the >>>> sealant and let it sit for 48 hours for the sealant to cure. At 48 >>>> hours the sealant is about 90% cured but it continues to cure for 72 >>>> hours. I couldn't wait that long. I attached a small piece of lexan >>>> (about 1.5" x 3") to a larger piece at a corner. I messed up the >>>> sealant with the result that I got some on top of the tape - which >>>> seems like a distinct possibility when I do the large panels so I >>>> was curious to see what effect that had. By leaving the smaller >>>> piece extending beyond the larger piece I had a tab that I could use >>>> to peal the pieces apart. I have attached a picture of what I call >>>> the "flex test". >>>> >>>> By holding the main piece down and lifting up on the tab I was able >>>> to bend the panels far beyond any curvature on the cabin side of the >>>> boat without any sign of the joint letting g. Also. the joint had >>>> enough flex that the panels could move past each other slightly to >>>> allow for a nice even bend. When I bent the joint to the maximum the >>>> lexan broke (see photo) before any sign that the joint was weakening. >>>> Lexan is very flexible and strong so that seemed to me to be a good >>>> sign although I should note that the Lexan was only 3/16" >>>> thick. I figure that if I can't break the join even on small pieces >>>> without destroying the Lexan, that has to be a very strong and >>>> flexible >>> joint. >>>> >>>> As an aside, the sealant has a useful life of one year. When I >>>> ordered mine it was already 8 months old and expired in March 2015. >>>> I called 3M last fall to see if there was any way to extend the life >>>> of the material. The technical support person told me to seal it up >>>> in plastic and put it in my freezer - which I did. He then told me >>>> to test it before using it by laying out a bead and letting it sit >>>> for 3 >> hours. >>>> If it skinned over, it was good but if it stayed wet it will never >>>> cure >>>> - even though it looks fine coming out of the tube. >>>> I Had thought that old material would harden in the tube so that was >>>> potentially very useful to know. I have read online where others >>>> complained that this sealant never cured and I expect they were >>>> using material that was too old. In my case it appears the freezing >>>> worked as the sealant cured up nicely. >>>> >>>> Although the acrylic panels I am using are dark tinted, I wanted to >>>> make sure that the grey tape and white sides of the cabin did not >>>> show through so I needed to find a suitable paint to coat the inside. >>>> I wanted something that would adhere tenaciously to acrylic so that >>>> in turn the tape and sealant would adhere to the paint. I also >>>> wanted something that would apply by spray to give a perfectly even >>>> coat and preferably was fast drying. Articles I read advised using >>>> engine exhaust paint. The particular types suggested were not >>>> available locally and a ridiculous price to order by mail across the >>>> Canada/US border. Also I noticed that application instructions for >>>> similar paints available locally specified that it dries easily but >>>> does not cure until it is brought up to a high heat. That , of >>>> course , is not going to happen with acrylic so I was left wondering >>>> how it would work in an uncured state. >>>> >>>> I experimented with a number of paints - especially paints that are >>>> intended for plastic. The first time I did this in 1995 I used some >>>> sort of enamel that subsequently pealed of even though it was >>>> between the Lexan and the cabin side. It was thick, soft and had >>>> poor adhesion with Lexan. So I wanted something better than that. I >>>> noticed that the paints I was testing went on thick and took a long >>>> time to dry. They also scratched off too easily for my liking. I >>>> then tried some barbeque paint that I had. The paint is intended for >>>> high heat applications but had a maximum temperature of 600 degrees >>>> - which is much lower than the exhaust paint but still much higher >>>> than anything the boat will ever face before I am jumping overboard >>>> and it does not require heat to cure. It also sprays on beautifully >>>> in thin coats, dries to touch in a few minutes - no dust problems - >>>> and can be recoated several time within an hour. That meant that I >>>> could apply multiple thin and even coats. It give! >>>> s a satin finish rather than high gloss which I thought might make >>>> a better surface for the tape to adhere to. I first painted pieces >>>> of Lexan and clear acrylic and let it sit for about 3 months to see >>>> if there was any indication of incompatibility between the paint >>>> and the plastic. There was no sign of incompatibility that I could see. >>>> >>>> I tested the adhesion of the paint by trying to scratch it off soon >>>> after application and after several months and by applying a variety >>>> of tapes - duct tape and packing tape, house wrap tape etc, - and >>>> then peal it back both while the paint was fresh and after the tape >>>> had been in place for several months. As the flex test shows I also >>>> tried adhesion with the double-sided tape and, as noted, the lexan >>>> broke before the seal showed any sign of letting go. I also applied >>>> sealant, let it cure , and tried to remove it by pealing it back. >>>> The "paint test" is shown in an attached picture. It shows packing >>>> tape that had been left in place for several months. The tape was >>>> firmly attached but came off cleanly leaving the paint firmly >>>> attached to the Lexan. Scratching the paint with a sharp object left >>>> a scratch, of course, but did not remove any of the surrounding >>>> paint. So I think this is a good paint for this application. >>>> >>>> To prepare the windows, I cut the acrylic panels from a 1/8" plywood >>>> template, routed a slight bevel on the outside edges, laid out where >>>> the opening in the cabin were, made a template for consistent >>>> openings made out of Formica (which works well because it is thin >>>> and >>>> hard) and then cut the protective paper around what will be the >>>> openings using the template and exacto knife. I then removed all the >>>> protective covering except where the openings will be and painted >>>> the pieces with four thin coats of barbeque paint. I have attached a >>>> photo of the painted pieces. >>>> >>>> After the acrylic is attached to the boat I will remove the masking >>>> tape on the outside of the acrylic panes, the tape on the cabin >>>> sides and remove the protective paper from the outside of the panels >>>> and the inside of the open part. I tested whether I would be able >>>> to peel off the inside sections once it had been painted over >>>> especially given that it will be difficult to raise an edge once the >>>> panels are installed. I found that if I apply a strip of packing >>>> tape to the covering paper leaving the end folded over so I can grab >>>> it, when I peal it back the tape holds sufficiently to raise the >>>> protective paper cleanly avoiding the need to scratch up an edge. >>>> Hopefully that works in the real life situation. I would hate to >>>> have acrylic panels permanently attached with paper coving the >>>> opening that I can't remove. >>>> >>>> So I have chosen all the materials and tested them as best I can for >>>> suitability. I have also worked out a temporary clamping system to >>>> hold the panels in place while the tape and sealant cure. That might >>>> be unnecessary but given the curve of the cabin I don't want to take >>>> a chance on that part. I have masked the boat around the edge of the >>>> acrylic and sanded the paint on the cabin side so that is flat , >>>> smooth but dulled (220 grit). Now all that is left is to attach the >>>> actual panels and frankly that is what worries me most. While online >>>> instructions suggest applying the tape and sealant to the panel and >>>> then apply the panel to the boat, my thinking is that because the >>>> cabin side is a compound curve I would be better to apply the tape >>>> and sealant to the cabin and then press the panel into place. >>>> >>>> Time matters. I don't have forever to apply the sealant and remove >>>> the tape cover before pressing the panel on and worse still, I only >>>> get one chance to get the panel in the exact location. There is >>>> really no room for error. I have "rehearsed" placing the panel with >>>> my wife but that was without any of the tape or sealant. The cabin >>>> side has a moulded in edge at both the bottom and the aft end that >>>> are very helpful guides but one still need to make sure from the >>>> moment of first touch that everything is aligned perfectly so that >>>> the rest will wrap into place exactly where it is supposed to be. My >>>> hope is that I can rest the bottom edge and aft corner against the >>>> little raised edge first and then wrap the piece up into place at >>>> the >> top. >>>> >>>> If anyone has any clever ideas about how I could make the process >>>> idiot proof I would be forever grateful. The idea of having to use >>>> a chisel and grinder to remove the misaligned panels has no appeal >>>> to me at this juncture. I think I will need a very good shot of >>>> Rummy's Mont Gay medicine to calm my nerves first. >>>> >>>> >>>> Graham >>>> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was >>>> scrubbed... >>>> Name: Barbeque paint.jpg >>>> Type: image/jpeg >>>> Size: 178369 bytes >>>> Desc: not available >>>> Url : >>>> http://www.rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20150602 >>>> / >>>> 91 >>>> 6312ae/attachment.jpg >>>> >>>> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was >>>> scrubbed... >>>> Name: Window flex test.jpg >>>> Type: image/jpeg >>>> Size: 52391 bytes >>>> Desc: not available >>>> Url : >>>> http://www.rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20150602 >>>> / >>>> 91 >>>> 6312ae/attachment-0001.jpg >>>> >>>> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was >>>> scrubbed... >>>> Name: Window paint test.jpg >>>> Type: image/jpeg >>>> Size: 82200 bytes >>>> Desc: not available >>>> Url : >>>> http://www.rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20150602 >>>> / >>>> 91 >>>> 6312ae/attachment-0002.jpg >>>> >>>> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was >>>> scrubbed... >>>> Name: Windows painted.jpg >>>> Type: image/jpeg >>>> Size: 54671 bytes >>>> Desc: not available >>>> Url : >>>> http://www.rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20150602 >>>> / >>>> 91 >>>> 6312ae/attachment-0003.jpg >>>> >>>> __________________________________________________ >>>> To subscribe/unsubscribe go to >>>> http://www.rhodes22.org/mailman/listinfo/rhodes22-list >>>> >>>> For the list Charter and help with using the mailing list and >>>> archives go to http://www.rhodes22.org/list >>>> __________________________________________________ >>>> >>>> >>>> ----- >>>> No virus found in this message. >>>> Checked by AVG - www.avg.com >>>> Version: 2015.0.5961 / Virus Database: 4355/9924 - Release Date: >>>> 06/02/15 >>> >>> __________________________________________________ >>> To subscribe/unsubscribe go to >>> http://www.rhodes22.org/mailman/listinfo/rhodes22-list >>> >>> For the list Charter and help with using the mailing list and >>> archives go to http://www.rhodes22.org/list >>> __________________________________________________ >>> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was >>> scrubbed... >>> Name: Windows with openings marked (2).jpg >>> Type: image/jpeg >>> Size: 173689 bytes >>> Desc: not available >>> Url : >>> http://www.rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20150603/ >>> 5 >>> 1cc1373/attachment.jpg >>> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was >>> scrubbed... >>> Name: Sailboat under cover Aug 08.jpg >>> Type: image/jpeg >>> Size: 242176 bytes >>> Desc: not available >>> Url : >>> http://www.rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20150603/ >>> 5 >>> 1cc1373/attachment-0001.jpg >>> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was >>> scrubbed... >>> Name: Paint for windows comparison.jpg >>> Type: image/jpeg >>> Size: 76907 bytes >>> Desc: not available >>> Url : >>> http://www.rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20150603/ >>> 5 >>> 1cc1373/attachment-0002.jpg >>> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was >>> scrubbed... >>> Name: Paint and peal test.jpg >>> Type: image/jpeg >>> Size: 210408 bytes >>> Desc: not available >>> Url : >>> http://www.rhodes22.org/pipermail/rhodes22-list/attachments/20150603/ >>> 5 >>> 1cc1373/attachment-0003.jpg >>> __________________________________________________ >>> To subscribe/unsubscribe go to >>> http://www.rhodes22.org/mailman/listinfo/rhodes22-list >>> >>> For the list Charter and help with using the mailing list and >>> archives go to http://www.rhodes22.org/list >>> __________________________________________________ >> >> __________________________________________________ >> To subscribe/unsubscribe go to >> http://www.rhodes22.org/mailman/listinfo/rhodes22-list >> >> For the list Charter and help with using the mailing list and archives >> go to http://www.rhodes22.org/list >> __________________________________________________ >> >> __________________________________________________ >> To subscribe/unsubscribe go to >> http://www.rhodes22.org/mailman/listinfo/rhodes22-list >> >> For the list Charter and help with using the mailing list and archives >> go to http://www.rhodes22.org/list >> __________________________________________________ > > __________________________________________________ > To subscribe/unsubscribe go to > http://www.rhodes22.org/mailman/listinfo/rhodes22-list > > For the list Charter and help with using the mailing list and archives go to > http://www.rhodes22.org/list > __________________________________________________ > > __________________________________________________ > To subscribe/unsubscribe go to http://www.rhodes22.org/mailman/listinfo/rhodes22-list > > For the list Charter and help with using the mailing list and archives go to http://www.rhodes22.org/list > __________________________________________________
To use your email application to send a messsage to the webmaster rather than this form, .
Your post is being sent... 