< prior
Back to Month
Go to Thread
2017-08-03; 14:06:14 EDT
Member Since
2002-08-24
Posts: 357
All the ideas sound pretty basic to what I had in mind. Does anyone have more details to David Culp’s solution from 2010? Found under "Fwd: [Rhodes22-list] Was Sails Now Boom Vangs” but no photo or any additional details- JaySee the original archive post
> Begin forwarded message: > > From: David Culp <dculp at hsbtx.com> > Subject: [Rhodes22-list] Was Sails Now Boom Vangs > Date: January 13, 2010 at 1:20:02 PM EST > To: rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org > Reply-To: The Rhodes 22 Email List <rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org> > > OK... I will get some good pictures of the parts, the operation and how to > build it. I have to take the operational pictures out on the water and if > it warms up a little more today, I may do it. > > In the meantime, to answer Lee's question: Yes, it will work on any point > of sail. Most effective when the boom is swung out over the water to the > farthest point and has its greatest tendency to rise. The closer the boom > is to the centerline of the boat, the less effective the device is until it > is nil when the boom reaches centerline. With boom end sheeting and a loose > footed main in the case of the IMF, you would bend the boom before being > able to noticeably tighten the sail when close to the wind. I use it on all > points of sail other then close-hauled and I have noticed it makes my tales > fly better even on a close reach. This appears more efficient, but it has > not translated into any performance increases that I can see. So anytime > the boom is completely over the boat, I don't worry about using it. Only > when the boom starts rising, do I deploy it depending on conditions; keeping > in mind that sometimes you want some belly in the sail downwind or to spill > some wind in high wind conditions and the boom rising up helps that. > > This is not rocket science by any means. I got the idea from reading about > how some off shore sailors disconnect their boom vangs from the mast base > and attach them to the rail to use as a preventer. That got me to wondering > if I could build a small boom vang with a purchase, attach it mid-boom on > the Rhodes and then fasten it to the rail in some manner. The trick was > finding the right rail attach point which would allow enough leverage on the > boom when downwind and still not interfere with the pop top arrangement. So > I experimented with several positions until I found a good compromise. > > To demonstrate the simplicity of it: Initially, I tied a loop of line > around the boom at about mid point and then treaded the other end through > the forward bimini attachment eye and played with that out on the water.... > Hey... it works and I don't have to hold the boom down by hand anymore. > > After that, it was just a matter of building something that could be easily > adjusted and quickly released to safely allow a tack or gybe and then able > to quickly attach the device to the other rail for the new point of sail. > The normal cleat/block combination found on a boom vang and a snap shackle > took care of that. If you are tacking a lot working upwind, you don't want > to use it. Requires more effort then it is worth because you must > disconnect it from the windward side and reconnect on the leeward side after > taking up the line that runs out when the boom crosses the boat. Running > downwind, broad or beam reaching, it's great! > > Todd and others: This is more of a home remedy then an invention. I know > you are kidding but the idea of patenting or selling anything is the last > thing on my mind. I am about 100 years too late and the parts are all > available at your favorite boat supply. My real hope is that someone else > may find it useful and/or improve upon it. If someone really wanted to > build something unique, they would figure out how to install a boom vang > from ABOVE the boom on the IMF that was adjustable for the different boom > positions. Sort of along the lines of what the Viper has. I would be > willing to pay for that. If the Rhodes was anything other then an > occasional weekend racer, Stan would have probably already figured that one > out. Those of us who have done a little racing know that 1/2 a knot is huge > when your hull speed is only 6. That's a 12% increase in speed downwind. > When just out cruising, if you are trying to cover a longer distance more > efficiently, then you may find this useful and that's my hope. > > David > > > From: r22rumrunner at aol.com > Subject: Re: [Rhodes22-list] Was Sails Now Boom Vangs > To: rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org > Message-ID: <f71a.4445681d.387e3353 at aol.com> > Content-Type: text/plain; charset="US-ASCII" > > David, > Rhodies are always interested in inventions. Any information you want to > share with the list would be greatly appreciated. > > Rummy > > > In a message dated 1/12/2010 3:01:01 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, > dculp at hsbtx.com writes: > > Since you guys brought this up and not me.... I will tell you that there is > a way to have a "boom vang/preventer" type apparatus on the Rhodes 22 that > works with the pop top up or down and the boom up or down. I have been > reluctant to mention it on this forum because it is an experimental, > personal project. However, like Mark McQuire I have decided to "come > clean" > with my Rhodes buds and budettes. I built it this last summer for about $ > 150.00 dollars and have been testing it since then with good results. It > is > not a true boom vang, but it does accomplish the three main things that I > wanted: > > 1. Keep the boom down and parallel to the deck running downwind with a > possible performance gain. > > 2. Prevent an accidental gybe. > > 3. Not interfere with the pop top or ingress/egress from the cabin and > works in either boom position. > > An unintended result of having it installed is my new ability to sail the > boat backwards. I did this initially to test > the structural integrity of the setup. Then it became a joke. You get > some > very interesting reactions from power boaters as you go by them sailing > your > Rhodes backwards. Perhaps even a few have given up drinking as a result > .... nah! Anyway, I was going to video it and put it up on YouTube. Still > coming, but my videographer who also participated in some of the testing is > very sick right now and I wanted to give him a shot a being a part of it. > > Issues: > > True boom vangs can be tightened and swing the full 180 degree travel of > the > boom. My system has two attach points and the tensioning line must be > released to run in the blocks in either a tack or gybe and then you have to > move the snap shackle to the other side and re-tension. However, it does > a > great job of controlling boom rise working downwind and really the Rhodes > doesn't need a boom vang except downwind in my opinion. In other words, > with a small, end-sheeted main, you really can't depower with a vang close > to the wind for a noticeable result. The traveler is much more effective > in > that regard. > > Accidental gybes have been tested up to wind speeds of approximately 12-13 > kts with good results but I wouldn't go much higher then that. My target > is > 15 kts., but so far haven't gotten to test in a known steady 15 kt wind. > The perfect system and there are some on the market, would allow a slow > release of the boom to gybe the boat. Otherwise, there are some huge > transitional loads put on the rig, tensioning lines and hardware of this > system or any system for that matter. Accidental gybes in a sailboat are > dangerous and never good for the rig regardless of what system is in place. > This preventer will prevent an accidental gybe, but even better, it gives > you more time to recognize that possibility and recover your course before > it happens. > > Should the normal Rhodes owner run out and put this on his/her boat? > Leaving it up to you, but most probably don't care. Would the manufacturer > of the boat recommend it? Probably not as presently designed. Has it > worked > well for me and been convincing to other sailors who have witnessed its > operation? Yes! Could you hurt yourself or damage your boat with it? > Maybe, if you are not paying attention and do stupid things in high winds. > Of course, that holds true in any sailing situation; so it is not > inherently dangerous. > > Now the most important thing: Did it increase the speed of the boat? > Yes. > My knot-meter tells me about .5 kts in winds 12-13 knots in relatively > smooth water. > > Someone wrote on this forum sometime time back that when they manually held > their boom down by hand going downwind... that it was worth about 1/2 a > knot. $ 150.00 dollars later, I can confirm that observation as being > pretty much true. There are a lot of factors that control boat speed and > your results may vary. > > In the final analysis; for most people, there are better ways to spend your > money for 1/2 a knot. For instance, a whisker pole for the Rhodes costs > about $ 150.00 dollars. If you want real performance downwind, put a > spinnaker on the boat. I was more interested in increasing efficiency with > the sails I have. I never have a crew and don't want a spinnaker, so this > is what I did. IT DOES WHAT I WANTED IT TO DO. Which is my definition of a > successful home project. If others are interested, post your comments and I > will build a webpage with photos fully explaining how to build it. It's > actually fairly simple. You will have to decide if it is worth it to you. > > David Culp > > Date: Tue, 12 Jan 2010 07:09:19 -0800 (PST) > From: Leland <LKUHN at cnmc.org> > Subject: [Rhodes22-list] Was Sails Now Boom Vangs > To: rhodes22-list at rhodes22.org > Message-ID: <27128980.post at talk.nabble.com> > Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii > > > Rummy, > > Since you brought up the winter topic and unlike you I won't be able to > sail > until the ice melts, how about them boom vangs? > > Someone on this list has a removable vang that can be used with the poptop > down but I normally sail with the poptop up and am too lazy to take a vang > on and off. > > I assume there is no practical means of keeping the boom down when the > poptop is up or Stan would have figured it out by now. A reverse rigid > vang-like apparatus installed higher up on the mast could push the boom > down > but would probably interfere with the sail. You could tie the end of the > boom down using strategically placed cleats but that could involve a lot of > cleats and a safety issue. Even less safe would be a bag of weights > hanging > off the end of the boom--might be exciting during tacks and jibes. > > Until someone comes up with a workable solution I guess I'll just keep > using > Boomer to hold things down, but my wife doesn't particularly like the title > or the job. > > Lee > 1986 Rhodes22 At Ease > Kent Island, MD > __________________________________________________ > To subscribe/unsubscribe go to http://www.rhodes22.org/mailman/listinfo/rhodes22-list > > For the list Charter and help with using the mailing list and archives go to http://www.rhodes22.org/list > __________________________________________________
To use your email application to send a messsage to the webmaster rather than this form, .
Your post is being sent... 